The Problem with Spotify's Search
Spotify is a streaming service that provides access to millions of songs, podcasts, playlists, and videos from artists around the world. Its interface features a home screen with personalized playlists and recommendations based on the user's listening habits.
I chose this application because I use Spotify daily, making it a platform I am deeply familiar with. While this familiarity allowed me to identify strengths and shortcomings, I challenged myself to capture perspectives from a broader range of users beyond my own demographic.
How We Listened to Users
One interviewer quietly observed and took notes while the other presented questions and tasks — capturing micro-decisions, hesitations, and errors that self-reporting alone would miss. Sessions were recorded via Zoom or in-person screen recordings.
- ◆Have you used a music streaming app before?
- ◆How often do you use Spotify?
- ◆What features do you like and dislike?
- ◆What device(s) do you use Spotify on?
- ◆What are your most used features?
- ◆Do you listen to Spotify's recommended playlists?
- ◆Find the R&B genre section
- ◆Find a section recommending new music
- ◆Add a playlist to your library
- ◆Find a podcast to listen to
- ◆Find an audiobook to listen to
- ◆Add one song to 3 different playlists
- ◆Download an album to your library
- ◆Turn on crossfade & change to 3 seconds
- ◆Queue 2 songs
- ◆What features did you like after tasks?
- ◆What features did you dislike?
- ◆Was there a feature you didn't know about?
- ◆Which was the most difficult task and why?
- ◆Which was the easiest task and why?
- ◆What would improve your experience on Spotify mobile?
Interviewee Profiles
Where Users Struggled
Discovery and navigation tasks were completed easily by all users. Difficulties arose around managing content and accessing playback settings — revealing Spotify's core discoverability problem.
"I didn't even know Spotify had audiobooks — where would you even find that?"
— Interview Participant, Round 1
Spotify Search: What's Broken
Spotify lacks lyric-based or humming search functionality available on Apple Music and YouTube Music. These features enhance discoverability for users who struggle to identify songs by title or artist alone.
The section below the search bar dedicates significant real estate to podcasts, audiobooks, and live events — which many users find irrelevant. Many users are unaware Spotify offers audiobooks, making their prominent placement ineffective.
Genres for music, audiobooks, and podcasts are randomly mixed with no filtering or grouping. Categories like "Country," "Pop," and "Podcast Charts" appear side by side without logic. Colors are inconsistent with no clear correlation between similar items.
The profile icon gives no indication that settings live inside it — no navigation entry, no affordance, no signifier. Even inside settings, Crossfade is not clearly surfaced. Users must navigate through every page to find it.
Users reported the Discovery section is more engaging and visually appealing than "Start Browsing." Placing Discovery higher, followed by relevant categories, could better align with how users actually approach the search page.
What Others Do Better
- — Lyric-based search — find songs by typing words you remember
- — Separate library vs. platform search for targeted results
- — Four prominent buttons: Music, Podcasts, Audiobooks, Live Events
- — Clear visual hierarchy between all content types
No audio/humming search; less integrated social discovery
- — Dictation + humming feature — search without knowing the title
- — Background overlay enhances mood context for playlists
- — Premade playlists surfaced directly in the search bar
- — Curated options with contextual filters within search itself
Filter buttons at top lack clear organization; labels like "feel good" are vague
- — "Vibes" section with varied box sizes reduces excessive scrolling
- — Search bar shows filtered suggestions with arrow-plug icons
- — Content per genre split into All, Trending, and Playlists tabs
- — Audio waveform icons on playing tracks improve usability
Niche user-uploaded focus limits mainstream music discovery
| Feature | Spotify | Apple Music | YouTube Music | SoundCloud |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lyric / Humming Search | ✗ | Lyrics only | ✓ Humming | ✗ |
| Media Type Filters | ✗ | ✓ | Partial | ✓ |
| Semantic Genre Grouping | ✗ | Partial | ✗ | ✓ |
| Blend / Mix Creation | ✓ (hidden) | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
| Crossfade | ✓ (buried) | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| Social / Community | Partial | ✗ | Comments | ✓ Full |
Two Redesigns, One Winner
Following a four-sketch ideation phase, two high-fidelity prototypes were built in Figma and tested against real users. Both addressed the Browse All clutter — but through different structural approaches.
Filter tabs moved directly under search bar; Discovery section repositioned above Browse All
Discover section at the top; Recently Browsed row added; Browse All reorganized by media type
Collapsible genre dropdowns to reduce scrolling; personalized recent search history
Microphone icon in search bar for audio identification; compact pill-style genre filters
Search bar at top → Discover New Music section → Most Recent Browses row → Browse All split into 4 categories: Curated Playlists, Genres, Podcasts, Live Events, Audiobooks. Blend/Mix creation entry point added.
Eliminates Start Browsing entirely. Persistent filter tabs — Music / Podcasts / Audiobooks / Live Events — pinned under search bar. Music auto-highlighted green. Only 6 genres shown by default with "See more genres" expansion. Microphone icon for Shazam-style audio search.
Testing the Redesigns
Not Missing Features.
Missing Discoverability.
We predicted users would quickly navigate sections to find different media types — and we were correct. Task difficulty averaged 1–2 out of 5, with no significant difficulties, confirming our design rationale holds across a diverse user group.
Since Spotify has many moving parts, it's critical that users can find things quickly without getting lost. By grounding every decision in user data — and recognizing that users mostly use Spotify for music — we created a redesign centered on music discoverability while still surfacing other features.
To the Head Designer
4 out of 4 users in User Testing #2 preferred Redesign #2. The filter tabs streamlined search and minimized confusion — remaining visible across pages so users can switch contexts without losing their place.
Replace the Start Browsing section with compact Music / Podcasts / Audiobooks / Live Events filter tabs pinned directly under the search bar. Auto-highlight Music as default. Filters remain visible across pages so users can switch without losing their place.
Group genres into logical clusters — general music genres, international, media-form (movies/games), and ambient/activity-based. Remove random ordering. Show 6 genres by default with a "See more genres" expansion to keep the page shorter.
Add a microphone icon to the search bar enabling Shazam-style audio search. When a song is identified, surface playlist-add, hide song, and "Find more like this in [genre]" actions — letting users explore without leaving the app.
Increase discoverability of Spotify's Blend and Mix features by adding an entry point directly within the Search page — addressing the common finding that users don't know about or can't find these features.
Relocate the Crossfade control to a prominent position — either surfaced in the Now Playing screen or in a clearly accessible Audio Settings shortcut — so users who know about it can actually find it.
Incorporate icons and subtle animations to make filter tabs and content type indicators more distinguishable. Add Saved and preference-based filter options so users can customize the order of categories to match their listening habits.
The Problem with Spotify's Search
Spotify is a streaming service that provides access to millions of songs, podcasts, playlists, and videos from artists around the world. Its interface features a home screen with personalized playlists and recommendations based on the user's listening habits.
I chose this application because I use Spotify daily, making it a platform I am deeply familiar with. While this familiarity allowed me to identify strengths and shortcomings, I challenged myself to capture perspectives from a broader range of users beyond my own demographic.
How We Listened to Users
One interviewer quietly observed and took notes while the other presented questions and tasks — capturing micro-decisions, hesitations, and errors that self-reporting alone would miss. Sessions were recorded via Zoom or in-person screen recordings.
- ◆Have you used a music streaming app before?
- ◆How often do you use Spotify?
- ◆What features do you like and dislike?
- ◆What device(s) do you use Spotify on?
- ◆What are your most used features?
- ◆Do you listen to Spotify's recommended playlists?
- ◆Find the R&B genre section
- ◆Find a section recommending new music
- ◆Add a playlist to your library
- ◆Find a podcast to listen to
- ◆Find an audiobook to listen to
- ◆Add one song to 3 different playlists
- ◆Download an album to your library
- ◆Turn on crossfade & change to 3 seconds
- ◆Queue 2 songs
- ◆What features did you like after tasks?
- ◆What features did you dislike?
- ◆Was there a feature you didn't know about?
- ◆Which was the most difficult task and why?
- ◆Which was the easiest task and why?
- ◆What would improve your experience on Spotify mobile?
Interviewee Profiles
Where Users Struggled
Discovery and navigation tasks were completed easily by all users. Difficulties arose around managing content and accessing playback settings — revealing Spotify's core discoverability problem.
"I didn't even know Spotify had audiobooks — where would you even find that?"
— Interview Participant, Round 1
Spotify Search: What's Broken
Spotify lacks lyric-based or humming search functionality available on Apple Music and YouTube Music. These features enhance discoverability for users who struggle to identify songs by title or artist alone.
The section below the search bar dedicates significant real estate to podcasts, audiobooks, and live events — which many users find irrelevant. Many users are unaware Spotify offers audiobooks, making their prominent placement ineffective.
Genres for music, audiobooks, and podcasts are randomly mixed with no filtering or grouping. Categories like "Country," "Pop," and "Podcast Charts" appear side by side without logic. Colors are inconsistent with no clear correlation between similar items.
The profile icon gives no indication that settings live inside it — no navigation entry, no affordance, no signifier. Even inside settings, Crossfade is not clearly surfaced. Users must navigate through every page to find it.
Users reported the Discovery section is more engaging and visually appealing than "Start Browsing." Placing Discovery higher, followed by relevant categories, could better align with how users actually approach the search page.
What Others Do Better
- — Lyric-based search — find songs by typing words you remember
- — Separate library vs. platform search for targeted results
- — Four prominent buttons: Music, Podcasts, Audiobooks, Live Events
- — Clear visual hierarchy between all content types
No audio/humming search; less integrated social discovery
- — Dictation + humming feature — search without knowing the title
- — Background overlay enhances mood context for playlists
- — Premade playlists surfaced directly in the search bar
- — Curated options with contextual filters within search itself
Filter buttons at top lack clear organization; labels like "feel good" are vague
- — "Vibes" section with varied box sizes reduces excessive scrolling
- — Search bar shows filtered suggestions with arrow-plug icons
- — Content per genre split into All, Trending, and Playlists tabs
- — Audio waveform icons on playing tracks improve usability
Niche user-uploaded focus limits mainstream music discovery
| Feature | Spotify | Apple Music | YouTube Music | SoundCloud |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lyric / Humming Search | ✗ | Lyrics only | ✓ Humming | ✗ |
| Media Type Filters | ✗ | ✓ | Partial | ✓ |
| Semantic Genre Grouping | ✗ | Partial | ✗ | ✓ |
| Blend / Mix Creation | ✓ (hidden) | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
| Crossfade | ✓ (buried) | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| Social / Community | Partial | ✗ | Comments | ✓ Full |
Two Redesigns, One Winner
Following a four-sketch ideation phase, two high-fidelity prototypes were built in Figma and tested against real users. Both addressed the Browse All clutter — but through different structural approaches.
Filter tabs moved directly under search bar; Discovery section repositioned above Browse All
Discover section at the top; Recently Browsed row added; Browse All reorganized by media type
Collapsible genre dropdowns to reduce scrolling; personalized recent search history
Microphone icon in search bar for audio identification; compact pill-style genre filters
Search bar at top → Discover New Music section → Most Recent Browses row → Browse All split into 4 categories: Curated Playlists, Genres, Podcasts, Live Events, Audiobooks. Blend/Mix creation entry point added.
Eliminates Start Browsing entirely. Persistent filter tabs — Music / Podcasts / Audiobooks / Live Events — pinned under search bar. Music auto-highlighted green. Only 6 genres shown by default with "See more genres" expansion. Microphone icon for Shazam-style audio search.
Testing the Redesigns
Not Missing Features.
Missing Discoverability.
We predicted users would quickly navigate sections to find different media types — and we were correct. Task difficulty averaged 1–2 out of 5, with no significant difficulties, confirming our design rationale holds across a diverse user group.
Since Spotify has many moving parts, it's critical that users can find things quickly without getting lost. By grounding every decision in user data — and recognizing that users mostly use Spotify for music — we created a redesign centered on music discoverability while still surfacing other features.
To the Head Designer
4 out of 4 users in User Testing #2 preferred Redesign #2. The filter tabs streamlined search and minimized confusion — remaining visible across pages so users can switch contexts without losing their place.
Replace the Start Browsing section with compact Music / Podcasts / Audiobooks / Live Events filter tabs pinned directly under the search bar. Auto-highlight Music as default. Filters remain visible across pages so users can switch without losing their place.
Group genres into logical clusters — general music genres, international, media-form (movies/games), and ambient/activity-based. Remove random ordering. Show 6 genres by default with a "See more genres" expansion to keep the page shorter.
Add a microphone icon to the search bar enabling Shazam-style audio search. When a song is identified, surface playlist-add, hide song, and "Find more like this in [genre]" actions — letting users explore without leaving the app.
Increase discoverability of Spotify's Blend and Mix features by adding an entry point directly within the Search page — addressing the common finding that users don't know about or can't find these features.
Relocate the Crossfade control to a prominent position — either surfaced in the Now Playing screen or in a clearly accessible Audio Settings shortcut — so users who know about it can actually find it.
Incorporate icons and subtle animations to make filter tabs and content type indicators more distinguishable. Add Saved and preference-based filter options so users can customize the order of categories to match their listening habits.
