The Problem with Slack's Interface
In a studio session at UCSD, a team of five identified Slack as a prime candidate for redesign. While the platform is powerful, its interface suffers from limited color differentiation, poor signifiers, and deeply nested features that users simply can't find.
The team set out to fix not the features themselves — but their discoverability.
How We Listened to Users
- ◆How long have you used Slack?
- ◆Primary use case?
- ◆Comfort level (1–10)
- ◆Other messaging apps used
- ◆Tech-savviness assessment
- ◆Create a new workspace
- ◆Accept an invitation
- ◆Send a direct message
- ◆Set vacation status
- ◆Find archived messages
- ◆Schedule a delayed message
- ◆Find mentioned threads
- ◆Use the Canvas feature
- ◆Create a poll
- ◆Rate navigation difficulty (1–5)
- ◆Rate app usefulness (1–5)
- ◆Features you'd like changed?
- ◆Features you'll use more?
- ◆Comparison to other platforms
Interviews followed the master-apprentice model — observing participants navigate the app with their own mental models, capturing micro-decisions and hesitations self-reporting alone would miss. Locations: Geisel Library, Sun God Lawn, home, and the gym.
Where Users Failed
Tasks 1–4 had zero errors. Tasks 5–9 exposed Slack's core issue: features exist but users cannot find them. All failures were knowledge-based mistakes stemming from poor signifiers, not user incompetence.
"Just feels like a worse version of Discord. Needing plugins for a workspace is inconvenient."
— Interview Participant
Design Space Mapping
Three Iterations to Clarity
Following the Double Diamond process, the team refined navigation through three distinct iterations.
- →Home, DMs, Activity tabs
- →Active page indicator present
- →DMs & Activity functions overlap
- →Monotone color scheme
- →Added profile button
- →New color scheme attempted
- →Icon redesign
- →Purple/black contrast issues
- →Black/white, purple on select
- →Home renamed to 'Workspace'
- →More consistent icon system
- →Needed further refinement
- →Purple/white high-contrast
- →White bubble active state
- →Profile button reduces clutter
- →Clear feedback on selected tab
Four Redesigned Pages
Replaced the cluttered 'Home' with a visual workspace grid. Color-coded tiles let users search, switch, and navigate workspaces instantly.
Chat previews kept under usernames. Activity/Mentions now shows pending invites prominently with direct links to tagged channels.
Archived messages relocated here — where 10/16 users looked first. This single change resolves the study's most common error.
Slash commands surfaced via a graph icon in the message bar. Polls, canvases, and plugins are now one tap away.
Every Design Decision has a Cost
Removing rarely-used items from primary nav forces users toward fewer, better-understood options.
A plugin search bar replaces the slash-command maze — trading power-user shortcuts for clarity.
The purple/white scheme sacrifices data density for cognitive clarity — a worthwhile trade for onboarding.
Moving archived messages to Profile breaks muscle memory for 6 users but rescues the other 10.
Not Bad Features.
Bad Signifiers.
Slack's core functionality is genuinely useful — 13/16 users rated its features highly. The problem is that users couldn't find them. Ambiguous icons, poor contrast, and nested menus created massive Gulfs of Evaluation.
The redesign surfaced existing features with clearer signifiers, improved color feedback, and navigation that matches users' mental models.
